Stuart Broad edged to first slip. Not out. Brad Haddin
feathered to the keeper. Not out. One apiece you would think.
To be clear, I have absolutely no problem with a player not
walking. In Year 12 I nicked one to first slip, stood my ground and was given
not out. The next ball I let everyone around me know I had smashed it, and told
the umpire I couldn’t believe he had missed it. I went on to make a match
winning score in our only win of the season but a week later I smashed one onto
my pads and was given out by the same umpire. Swings and roundabouts as they
say.
For over100 years Test match cricket has functioned
perfectly fine on the premise that umpires umpire and players play. Quite
simply that’s how it should be.
England can point to the dismissal of Jonathon Trott as the
evener for Stuart Broad’s howler but Phillip Hughes 51% of the ball pitching in
line with leg stump was just as contentious as Trott’s.
At the end of the day this has been one of the best Test
matches of my lifetime, without a doubt top three, and the focus of this
article is the Decision Review System.
I guess its well played to England. They won the Test match by using their
reviews better than the other team. Because after all that’s what cricket is
all about isn’t it?
Call me a whinger if you like but I hate the DRS. Always
have and always will. We were better off without it when Dar’s Broad clanger
would have paid for itself with another chance for Brad Haddin at the death.
The result might not have changed but at least we would have poetic justice.
The best news about it all is that the cricket is back on
Thursday. Strap yourself in!!
If they would use the DRS for the obvious howler I'd have no issue with it(although I wonder about the accuracy of Hawkeye when it comes to eg pitching 51% in-line decisions etc), but the constant interruptions make it a farce, that and the fact that the players seemingy use it more to save their ego, not to wait to be able to appeal against the obvious bad decision.
ReplyDeleteIf you want a video review system it needs to go into umpires hands. As it stands it hasn't improved the game in any way shape or form. As you say the standing around waiting is a farce and releases pressure and tension from a game built upon it
ReplyDelete